Showing posts with label Supreme. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Supreme. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

Supreme Court Limits Lawsuits Against Vaccine Makers

Vaccine makers such as Pfizer (PFE) are breathing much easier today: The Supreme Court ruled they can't be sued for defective vaccine designs. That puts the kibosh on some 5,000 cases in which parents blame vaccines for their children's autism, and generally gives the pharmaceutical companies much more certainty about their potential liability. The decision was 6-2, with Justice Elena Kagan sitting out. Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Ruth Bader Ginsburg dissented.

When a product hurts someone, one possible way the victim can sue is to claim that the product was designed defectively. Claiming a defective design is the tricky, because products can be inherently dangerous, but still be good products -- chainsaws or cars, for example. While different courts use different tests to determine if a design was defective, the basic idea is to strike a balance between the product's usefulness as intended and the risks it creates.

Let's apply this to a hypothetical vaccine: Imagine it's possible to have a vaccine that has no side effects, but isn't particularly effective at preventing the disease it targets, and another formulation that's extremely effective at disease prevention, but does have side effects, including -- in very rare cases -- horrible ones such as brain damage or even death. Because of society's interest in promoting the use of effective vaccines -- when someone fails to immunize their child, both that child and other people are put at risk, particularly infants and the elderly -- Congress has emphatically endorsed vaccines that are effective but have some rare risks as the better design.

To prevent vaccine makers from being bankrupted by lawsuits over those rare but horrible side effects, Congress created a special vaccine compensation program for victims. If a victim's claim is rejected by that program, the victim can still sue under state law, claiming the vaccine was defective. In the case the Court just decided, the issue was whether Congress allowed all kinds of defective vaccine claims, or just claims a vaccine was defectively manufactured or defectively marketed (i.e.: that the maker failed to warn users of known risks.)

Justice Scalia: A Strict Constructionist and a Strict Grammarian

The court heard the case of Hannah Bruesewitz, who developed a seizure disorder and mental disabilities as an infant, shortly after being given Wyeth's DPT vaccine. (Wyeth is now part of Pfizer.) Her family's claim for compensation was rejected by the federal program, and they turned to state court, alleging the vaccine was defectively designed because Wyeth owned a different design that was safer, but chose not to market it. Wyeth disputes the claim that the other design was safer.

In deciding the Bruesewitz's claim was barred, the Court turned to the text and structure of the law creating the federal compensation program. Effectively the decision turned on what the three words "even though" and "unavoidable" meant in this context:

"No vaccine manufacturer shall be liable [for] a vaccine-related injury or death...if the injury or death resulted from side effects that were unavoidable even though the vaccine was properly prepared and was accompanied by proper directions and warnings." (bold added)
Justice Scalia, a famous textualist, wrote the opinion. The majority decided that the language meant that only manufacturing and marketing defects, which follow the "even though", are allowed. If design defects were allowed, it should have said something like "properly prepared and designed and accompanied..." The dissent disagreed, arguing that the word "unavoidable" had a special meaning from a law treatise, which changed the analysis, and Congress hadn't clearly said it was preempting the state claims. Finally, the dissenters emphasized that shielding vaccine makers from design defect cases eliminates a powerful incentive for manufactures to keep improving their designs. As to the last argument, Scalia conceded the tort liability motive for design improvement was indeed eliminated by his opinion, but insisted the law provided other incentives.

Scalia, who has a reputation for witty, readable and caustic opinions, clearly reveled in parsing the sentence's structure as well as talking trash (in polite Supreme Court fashion) about Sotomayor and Ginsburg's dissent. For example, Justice Scalia noted that the "even though" clause is known as a "concessive subordinate clause by grammarians" and said things like "dissent's principal textual argument is mistaken ... We do not comprehend ... its reasoning."

Justice Scalia also took a passing swipe at Congress, noting that it had been unnecessarily wordy:

"Petitioners and the dissent contend that the interpretation we propose would render part of [the vaccine law] superfluous: ... ("the injury or death resulted from side effects that were unavoidable even though") is unnecessary. True enough. But the rule against giving a portion of text an interpretation which renders it superfluous does not prescribe that a passage which could have been more terse does not mean what it says."
At the end of the day, vaccine makers win. Society also wins -- especially if the vaccine makers' threats of withdrawing from the business if they lost this case were sincere. But the Bruesewitz family loses, painfully, as their now teenage daughter still suffers from the seizure condition and mental disabilities. And if the dissent is right, and manufacturers will fail to improve their vaccine designs as a result of the decision, we will all lose eventually as side effects that could have been reduced or eliminated continue to hurt people. Abigail Caplovitz Field View all Articles » Abigail Caplovitz Field is an attorney with a solo general practice on Shelter Island, New York. After graduating from NYU Law with honors in 2001, she worked as an associate for a major corporate law firm in New York City, and then as a consumer and good government lobbyist for the New Jersey Public Interest Research Group. Her lobbying duties included identity theft prevention, financial privacy and health care. She's written on topics as diverse as pharmaceutical marketing, toxic pollution, and racial profiling.

Read More

View the original article here

Saturday, February 5, 2011

Foreclosures in Paradise: Will the Supreme Court Review Hawaii's Flawed System?

Among the many state systems governing foreclosure in this country, Hawaii has particularly draconian -- and nonjudicial -- process. It's based on a law that dates back to 1874, a statute that was a key mechanism used to take land away from native Hawaiians and whose history is riddled with fraud. Although Hawaiian law also allows for judicial foreclosures, the nonjudicial process -- when no judge is involved in the proceeding -- is much more commonly used.

But for those suffering under Hawaii's foreclosure system, the question is: Can there be any relief?

Suzanne Bonds is a Hawaii resident who was unbelievably exploited by the state's foreclosure process in 2004, but all her efforts to challenge what happened were rejected by Hawaii's courts. Now, her attorneys have asked the U.S. Supreme Court to intervene. Given the massive foreclosure tide swamping the nation, and the fact that the judiciary is regularly confronting fraud even in states where a judicial process is required for a lender to take a person's home, a hard look at the fairness of systems in the less-protective nonjudicial foreclosure states is crucial.

Bonds's petition was submitted on Jan. 22, 2011, and the other side has 30 days to file a brief urging the high court not to take the case. Gary Victor Dubin, Bonds's lawyer, doesn't expect the court to decide until late March whether or not it will take the case. If it does, a decision on the merits could be a year after that.

(Note: Unless otherwise linked, the information discussed below is drawn solely from the petition. No response brief has yet been filed.)

Hawaii's Foreclosure Statute in Action

Bonds was in her early 70s in 1998, when she inherited her Hawaii home from her husband. In 2001, she took out a mortgage with Ameriquest Home Mortgage, a notoriously predatory lender. By early 2004, Bonds was 78 and in terrible shape: Physically and mentally ill, she suffered from "heart failure, dementia and advanced state of senility, and psychotic and bipolar disorders" according to her physicians.

Nonetheless in May, 2004 she was sent a letter saying that her property had been sold at public auction a month earlier. In her condition, she took no action until a concerned "care-giving church official" reviewed the letter and helped her get a lawyer. To add insult to injury, the bank sold the property for $634,900, a price at best half of what it was worth, meaning that the purchaser made an immediate and massive profit, while Bonds was stripped of substantial equity.

Not coincidentally, the buyers of Bonds's home have made such purchases before: They seem to have a business model based in part on buying auctioned Hawaii properties for much less than they're worth. At the time, Hawaii's foreclosure law required purchasers to arrive at the auction with 100% of the purchase price, which made mortgage financing impossible. That tends to limit competitive bidding: Not many people or companies can come up with $600,000 cash on short notice.

This 100% down problem was theoretically fixed by a statute allowing buyers to pay 10% at auction. However, as interpreted by the federal court, the "fix" allows the auctioning lender to require the balance in 30 days or less, which again makes obtaining mortgage financing almost impossible. As a result, Dubin explained, foreclosure sales function as before, with little competition.

Making matters worse for Bonds, the auction notice for her house seemed screwy, suggesting that not all the potential competition was made aware of the impending sale. The brief says the property was listed with "a material misdescription, in virtually unreadable, blurred type."

Can't Challenge the Foreclosures

Bonds tried to challenge the foreclosure on many grounds: Her original mortgage violated the federal Truth in Lending Act (not surprising for an Ameriquest mortgage). The bank breached the mortgage contract because she never received the foreclosure notice it required. And, given her health, she was entitled to, but didn't get, protections under the federal and Hawaiian versions of the Americans with Disabilities Act.

All her efforts -- and her lawyers took the case to Hawaii's Supreme Court -- failed. Once title was transferred, the courts decided, nothing could be done. It didn't matter that the title was transferred before Bonds had a clue that a sale was scheduled, much less completed. It didn't matter that Bonds had a variety of state and federal claims arising from the mortgage and the foreclosure. Once the title had been transferred, it became too late. When the deed was done, the deed was done.

So her lawyers have filed a petition with the U.S. Supreme Court, asking it to decide whether or not Hawaii's nonjudicial foreclosure statute violated Bonds's due process rights and the Constitution's supremacy clause. The supremacy clause claim arises because the federal consumer protection laws her mortgage violated are in effect being trumped by the state foreclosure law.

How Much of the Foreclosure Is the State's Fault?

If the test of due process were purely fundamental fairness, then Bonds would surely win. But it's not: The Constitution only requires government to be fundamentally fair. Private citizens can exploit and cheat each other with impunity. So the big question raised by Bonds case is this: Does the state, whether Hawaii or the federal government, play a sufficiently large role in this story for the foreclosure to be considered "state action"?

Sponsored Links The petition defines the "question presented" as a narrow view of state action: Is it state action to interpret state law to uphold a foreclosure when the borrower had no idea the foreclosure was occurring, and had valid, but as yet unlitigated, state and federal claims against the lender? The state actor in that case would be the Hawaii court system. However, the brief also offers a federal basis for finding state action: Fannie Mae's and Freddie Mac's role in mortgages and foreclosures.

The petition asserts that the way Hawaii mortgages are written, and the way foreclosures in Hawaii are conducted, is largely dictated by Fannie and Freddie, two government-sponsored enterprises. For example, most mortgages are made in forms Fannie and Freddie created, and both have instructed lenders to use nonjudicial foreclosures to save money, even though judicial foreclosures, with their attendant protections, are allowed under Hawaii law.

A Chance to Draw Boundaries

The Supreme Court ought to agree to hear this case. The abuses in the foreclosure fraud and mortgage mess playing out across the country are at their worst in nonjudicial foreclosure states. The Bonds case is an opportunity for the justices to lay down some basic boundaries of fairness in the foreclosure system. Moreover, it's an opportunity for the court to clarify its muddled state action doctrine, an opportunity the justices might appreciate.

And as Dubin explained to me, " The odds of Supreme Court review would greatly improve if other serious practitioners defending against nonjudicial foreclosures nationwide would seek leave of of court now to file amicus briefs in support, describing their clients' own contractual and due process violations and urging review."

Of course, if the court takes the case and finds there was no state action involved, ratifying what happened to Bonds, that would be a disaster for homeowners. But if it finds state action by the Hawaii court system, that will be great for borrowers in Hawaii, and potentially helpful elsewhere, depending on the court's reasoning.

However, if it finds state action through Fannie and Freddie, that would be most helpful of all, immediately giving borrowers a crucial precedent to challenge nonjudicial foreclosure procedures in California, Texas and 25 other "nonjudicial" states. That's a lot of Americans waiting to see how this case will play out.